L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner, Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant, Glides on Easily to Create any Look, Burgundy, 0.042 oz.

I’ve been very impressed with this eyeliner pencil. It glides on smoothly without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around my eyes, making application quick and easy. The color goes on evenly and provides great definition. What I love most is how long-lasting it is. Once applied, it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading, and I rarely need any touch-ups. Even after a full day of wear, it still looks fresh. If you’re looking for an eyeliner that is easy to apply, comfortable to wear, and truly long-lasting, this is an excellent choice. I will definitely continue purchasing it.

This is a great eyeliner pen I have used for some time. I particularly love the bronze brown color, it’s really pretty with my brown eyes that have gold accents in them. This eyeliner generally does not smudge. I have wet, oily eyelids and so I reinforce all eyeliners with a powder coat to set in place for good and this doesn’t smudge. It applies super easily too, has a nice variety of colors available for anyone. The one thing I would change would be not having to sharpen a pencil. I personally think it wastes so much product and you can never keep the sharpener clean. Still, overall, my favorite eyeliner out there.

Creamy smooth application and rich color. Glides on beautifully yet is forgiving of mistakes. Bronze shade isn't too sparkly. It's a dark brown and I'd have preferred it a touch lighter but it looks good either way. Can't comment on longevity since I've just applied but will update later. UPDATE: Since I got this, I've found that the longevity is excellent. Once you apply it, it starts to dry quickly so if you make a mistake, you have to move fast to correct. But it lasts all day and even overnight very well. It won't be all there, but still very visible. It doesn't smear so it's difficult to smoke out, if that's the look you are after. Love it though and have since ordered the Ivy (a greenish gray) and Eggplant (deep purple) colors.

I bought this specifically for tight lining my upper lids. I have very fair eyelashes and wear brown mascara. I still struggled with my eyes looking how I wanted them to. Bought this eyeliner on a whim to try the tight lining and it is exactly what I didn’t know I needed. Smooth application, beautiful rich brown color. I took one star off because I need to reapply after a couple of hours because it will wear off in spots, making my lashes look weird. I wish it would stay out longer.

Totally waterproof!! This goes on and stays on great!! This is the best eyeliner I've found at staying in place and working with my lack of artistic talent. Caveat: once the original factory sharpened point is hone, you'll have to grind half the pencil to sharpen. This is frustrating and makes it more expensive than the price makes it seem.

Love this eyeliner I bought it two or three times now never budged

I really like the color a lot. I like the ease of how it goes on and it lasts a few hours. But it's easily used up in one application. It has to be sharpened every time. I do not like the fact that it is too soft and breaks off easily in my pencil sharpener. The pencil itself did not last long at all and was used up really fast. It would be great if they could make it a roll-up eyeliner instead.

My eyes are finicky, so I am not surprised this doesn't stay on my waterline, though disappointed. I have many friends that swear by this product, AND wear contacts - I can't wear contacts either. I also couldn't get the product to sharpen, and went straight to L'Oreal and they have this answer (below). I can't really complain. Decent product, nice colors, just doesn't work for me. You: How do I sharpen my infallible eye liner? L’Oréal:Don't be fooled by the plastic resin that surrounds the liner, this pencil is sharpened with a separate pencil sharpener, and does not swivel up. To sharpen the pencil between each use, we recommend using a quality cosmetics sharpener like our L'Oreal Dual Sharpener. For best results, turn the pencil gently 3 or 4 times, being careful not to apply excess pressure. After sharpening, carefully remove all shavings from the blade edge. The pencil should be sharpened frequently so that 3 or 4 gentle turns are enough to achieve a working tip. Don't forget that eventually, your blade will wear down. If you are no longer getting a good point on your liners, it may be time to replace your sharpener.

Beautiful colour, long wear time, no smudging, no raccoon eyes after 10+ hours. Needs a good sharpener as the wood is hard. I will definitely buy this again rather than spending $20+ for a Lise watier metallic brown pencil (not retractable either) which doesn't last as long and smudges by the end of the day. I wish there would be more metallic colours like this one.

Just loved it, it lasts all day, easy to remove with vaseline.

Muy bueno, lo recomiendo

I received it broken

Love this color. I always get compliments. It stays all day. A little difficult to get off but I love it so much!