e.l.f.No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented, Coffee

Doesn’t fade and stays put. You have to do a couple of passes to get it to your desired color but it’s great other than that. Great and easy application to the waterline.

For the price, this product is worth it. I found it easy to apply and it didn't smudge in the hot outdoor temperatures.

Pro: I like the brown color, softness and it glides well with the sharp point along the eye line on both upper and lower lashes. I was careful to let it set for 30 seconds so it wouldn't smudge, and it lasted all day for me. I didn't remove it with anything, just washed my face with tepid water and in the morning nothing was on my silk pillowcase so that was fine with me. I can't comment on how waterproof it is, but it has great smudge resistance once set.Con: I've only used it once, so I have no idea how long it will last yet. It doesn't have a built-in sharpener and crayon is quite thin so I'm not giving it 5 stars until I've had it long enough. If Amazon allows an update, I'll do a followup review.

I literally just put this in the cart to get to the same day shipping minimum for something urgently needed, but I am glad I picked it. I wore this for the first time to an amusement park, so I can say it is rollercoaster proof.A lot of times, I end up with this extra arc of black where eyeliner meets the deeper part of my eyelid, and this was no exception. At this point, I think it is unavoidable. For five bucks, I don't expect much. I would say it was a thinner and fainter streak than some $12 eyeliner I have used, which absolutely counts for something, but it did transfer a bit despite giving every effort for it to be totally dry/done before relaxing.Otherwise, it held up really well, stayed put. Easy to apply, I actually usually prefer liquid liner but this was a lot easier/forgiving.

I use this stuff religiously. It’s smudges so perfectly, but it totally stays in other ways. I use it to fill in when I stamp my eyebrows on with the mad love stuff. I use this to fill in Anything that didn’t quite cover and this stays all day it never smudges ever even though it does smudge beautifully when you’re trying to smudge it once it set it doesn’t move and it is the perfect color brown for eyebrows if you’re a brunette.

I bought two of these pencils. Love the color, dark gray. One of the pencils appeared to not roll up, after inspection, I could see the lead (?) was stuck in the top cover. I was able to get it out by hitting on a table. When I picked up to try to put back in the pencil, the lead fell apart. Not happy that I paid for two pencils but can only use one.

Another solid ChatGPT recommendation! This eyeliner goes on smoothly, doesn’t tug, and the retractable design means no sharpening needed, which I love. It seems to hold up well for everyday wear but I don’t wear it often. I don’t feel much eye irritation and is super affordable. Probably something I’ll keep reordering.

The e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner in Coffee is an affordable and versatile eyeliner that delivers strong pigmentation and smooth application. The creamy formula glides effortlessly across the skin, making it easy to create both bold and subtle looks without tugging on the delicate eye area. The retractable design is convenient, eliminating the need for sharpening and ensuring a mess-free experience.One of its strongest points is its rich pigmentation—the deep coffee brown shade is perfect for those who want definition without the harshness of black. It works well for tightlining, smudging out for a softer effect, or even as a base for a smoky eye.However, while it claims to be "no budge," it isn't entirely smudge-proof, especially on oily lids or in humid conditions. It holds up decently for everyday wear but may require setting with a bit of powder or eyeshadow to prevent fading or transferring over time. Longevity is respectable, though not completely all-day wear for those with naturally oily eyelids.Overall, this is a great budget-friendly option that performs well for the price. If you’re looking for an ultra-pigmented, easy-to-use eyeliner with a smooth formula, this is worth trying—just be mindful of potential smudging depending on your skin type and wear time.