SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner 1 Matte Black

When I apply burning my eyes

I haven’t tried too many different high end brands of eyeliner, but time and time again, this one is the one I keep going back to despite it costing a little more compared to brands that are commonly found in drug stores, Walmart, and Target because its incomparably better. Those other brands are okay and I’ve tried them all, but one thing I notice is that it’s so hard to apply. I have to press so hard and drag the eyeliner pencil across my lids with a lot of force that they stretch my skin and it hurts. The eyeliner pencil itself is too dry and so is the application, therefore it’s hard to blend as well. It’s near impossible to achieve that dark and sometimes smoky look. With this eyeliner, it just glides right on, and one single line is enough to get that dark, saturated, and clean line. It stays moist on your eyes for a couple of seconds so that you can smudge and alter the eyeliner to however you want it. Then once it sets, it stays there all day. Ive worn a large winged look before and it doesn’t look dry and crease your skin either, which is lovely. It isn’t liquid liner though so even though it stays there all day, beware to not rub or scratch your eyes. I’ve fallen asleep with my makeup on by accident many times and it stays almost completely flawless until the next morning. If anything, I wake up with a surprisingly good smoky look haha. I love, love this brand and eyeliner!

Was looking for an eyeliner that doesn't smudge throughout the day and give me raccoon rings. After reading the reviews I thought I found a good one. While it is a good eyeliner, it maxes out at about 4ish hours for me before it starts running under my eyes. easy to wipe away and reapply. And it does NOT smudge and smear as obviously and bad as many other eyeliners do. Maybe it's my skin, rating 4 until I find a perfect eyeliner that doesn't smudge throughout an 8 hour work day.

Best eyeliner I've found yet. I put it on my inner eyelids/waterline. Perfect dark, rich, black color. Goes on smooth every time and stays on.The eyeliner has lasted me a while, and it's still going, so I'm definitely getting my money's worth. That being said, I don't use the sharpener on the other side of the sponge tip. If I did, I would suspect that the product wouldn't last as long. I use this eyeliner with ELF eye primer on my outer eyelids. Can't say enough good things. A keeper for any girls makeup collection. Item measures just shy of 5.5 inches in length. Fits in my 7 inch wide, 16 inch long, travel makeup pouch.

Did not go on as smoothly or last as long as Malley brand

I bought this Sephora waterproof eyeliner first a few years back. It worked great, I reordered, worked great still. It was out of stock for a while, so I looked for something locally. I must have bought five or six different brands and versions of a black waterproof eyeliner - Maybelline, Cover Girl, Loreal, etc. (I typically shop at the local drugstore for my makeup). None of them came close. I didn't wear eyeliner much because of it. Then I remembered Sephora and it was back in stock on Amazon. Ordered the black waterproof and felt like coming home. I'm giving it only 4 stars because this last purchase seemed like it wasn't quite as dark as the last two (I use it just at the root of the eyelashes on the inner eye). Still good but hoping the formula hasn't changed. A little pricey compared to my other trials but worth it to get the smooth application and true waterproof nature.