Buckeyes Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter, Gift Box, 11 oz

These are fantastic peanut and chocolate truffles. Top shelf from my point of view. I’m going to order more only twice as many as my first order! They are that good and creamy.

I ordered these because I needed a good peanut butter & chocolate Candy to replace the Dove variety which were sadly discontinued by the company. I like them. The peanut butter filling is smooth, & the chocolate is also tasty. But I must complement Fannie Mae for the hands down best packaging I’ve ever seen! My box of Candy came in a sturdy cardboard box lined with quilted cardboard & filler forms, along with a heavy duty cold pack! Very impressive, & even tho this was a summer order, there was no melting, discoloration, etc. Just fresh firm Buckeyes!! I will definitely order again.

The package was shipped with an ice pack and insulation. But the ice pack was warm 90 degrees outside. They were stinky, so I put the package in my refrigerator for a couple hours and everything turned out fine. Great chocolates, worth the extra care.

Fannie May always good

The best ever!! A little expensive, but worth the price.

The plastic part of the packaging that holds the truffles is deep enough for it to be a pain to get the truffles out, but not deep enough to prevent them from melting and getting disfigured. 7 out of the box weren’t melted and then hardened. The melted ones tasted disgusting. I couldn’t find a date on the box and am questioning how fresh they are. These were delivered in Minnesota in February so the melting was definitely not due to weather. As a lover of peanut butter I hate to say this, but I would not recommend these to anybody with taste buds.

These come in a nice sealed box, great for gifts. There is little if any variance in flavor from the dark brown parts of this candy to the light brown parts of this candy. They are made to resemble buckeyes, but are obviously manufactured to look that way. They are just OK to me. They are tasty candies, but I do not really notice the peanut butter flavor much. Overall, I recommend these for purely the value, but they are not the greatest buckeye candies I have ever had.

The delivery of the candy was just in time. It was a birthday gift for one of my friends whom I share a meal table with in the independent living apartments. She is a big peanut butter fan so we knew she would like it. She did share them with the table, but unfortunately both of us were out on appointments and missed lunch. Of course the other table mates raved about them. They were a good choice