Some deliveries may take a little longer than usual due to regional shipping conditions.
DOWNLOAD THE APP
Customer Services
Copyright © 2025 Desertcart Holdings Limited
DOWNLOAD THE APP
🧀 Elevate every bite with Wisconsin’s creamy Colby classic!
Shullsburg Creamery’s Colby Cheese is a 1-pound block of mild, creamy cheese made from pasture-raised cows in Wisconsin. Celebrated since 1874, this versatile cheese melts beautifully and pairs perfectly with a variety of dishes, earning a 4.3-star rating for quality and flavor.
| ASIN | B01MU7OY64 |
| ASIN | B01MU7OY64 |
| Animal Production Method | Pasture Raised |
| Best Sellers Rank | #135,678 in Grocery & Gourmet Food ( See Top 100 in Grocery & Gourmet Food ) #26 in Colby Cheese |
| Brand Name | Shullsburg Creamery |
| Coin Variety 1 | Colby |
| Container Type | Individual |
| Cuisine | American cuisine |
| Customer Reviews | 4.3 4.3 out of 5 stars (34) |
| Flavor | Colby |
| Is Discontinued By Manufacturer | No |
| Item Form | Cream |
| Item Weight | 16 ounces |
| Item Weight | 1 Pounds |
| Manufacturer | Shullsburg Creamery |
| Manufacturer | Shullsburg Creamery |
| Number of Items | 1 |
| Number of Pieces | 1 |
| Size | 16.0 Ounce (Pack of 1) |
| UPC | 026542059931 |
| UPC | 026542059931 |
| Unit Count | 16.0 Ounce |
| Units | 16.0 Ounce |
R**L
Shullberg Colby cheese
Colby cheese was great.
W**E
Excellent quality and flavor at a fair price
My wife really likes Colby and it's not easy find. My wife loves this. She says excellent quality and flavor.
A**R
Great cheese. Worth the effort to order from Amazon.
Great cheese. Superior to anything I can buy locally. So Amazon purchase it is!
D**S
NOT FOR ME
I WENT BY THE OTHER REVIEWS AND BOY I SHOULD NOT HAVE DONE THAT I WAS TRYING TO FIND A SOFTER COLBY A LITTLE CREAMY AND THIS IS THE HARDEST DRYEST CHEESE I HAVE EVER EATEN. NOT A FAN!
K**R
This product is the best cheese I've ever tasted! Shullsburg will have my cheese order from now on.
This product arrived cold, before the time frame given, and the team at Shullsburg creamery are amazing. I love Colby cheese and so does my dad. I ordered 1lb for my dad. I tasted the cheese and ordered 2lbs myself. This is the absolute best Colby cheese I have ever tasted. It is rich and very creamy. I am overly excited about this company and their cheese products. I hope anyone who sees this review orders from them. Shullsburg your cheese and your team are AMAZING! THANK YOU!!!!
M**N
Good Cheese, way overpriced
A mild cheese with a smooth, creamy texture. Melts well. We live in dairy land, so we can get good Colby Cheese at any supermarket, but we bought this brand in our search of a more mature, stronger flavored cheese with a slightly crumbly texture. And YES, we know the cheese of our quest exists, having had it many times in our distant youth. This is a good cheese, but the flavor and texture are not what we were after, and the cost was almost 4X what we pay for similar supermarket colby.
J**B
Schullsburg Cheese
I love colby/longhorn cheese but I cannot find it in any grocery store so I ordered some through Amazon. The one-pound block of Schullsburg colby cheese I ordered arrived well-wrapped, cold and on the date promised. I have previously ordered this cheese and was very please with the product, including the taste. The current block has not disappointed and I am very pleased with the entire transaction and the product.
D**K
Good cheese and service
It is hard to find real Colby cheese. I found it here and it is terrific. The shipment came as they said it would. Nice fresh cheese.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
3 weeks ago