Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner with Antioxidant Vitamin E, Water-Resistant & Smooth-Gliding Eyeliner Makeup, Dark Brown, 0.014 oz

This eyeliner is a dream! The dark brown shade is softer than black, perfect for enhancing mature eyes. It glides on effortlessly, lasts all day, and blends beautifully for a smoky effect. A true gem in any kit!

This is the only eyeliner I've used for the past 2 years. I've tried others and this has exactly the smudged line that looks best on my top lid. And the color is great--I have brown eyes but it's hard to imagine an eye color this won't look on. My biggest fear is that they're going to stop manufacturing it because it's getting more difficult to find, which is why I usually buy 2-3 at time!

I have tried all kinds of different eyeliner from cheap to very expensive. This is by far the best eyeliner I have ever bought! A little goes a long way! It goes on smooth and the pigments are amazing! Perfect for waterlines and stays put!I have hooded eyelids and everything I’ve tried would either transfer on to my eyelids or smudge and build up in the corners of my eyes. This amazing eyeliner stays in place. So I took my testing of it one step further and went swimming with 4 nieces. I kept asking my older niece (18 years old) if it was running all over my face and she was highly impressed it stayed in place. So not only did I buy my daughter some who has the same eyes as I do, I sent my niece home with a new set as well.I highly recommend this eyeliner to anyone with hooded eyelids, oily skin, or to those who want it to last and look fresh all day. I promise you won’t be disappointed!

It gives a softer, more natural line than the liquid eyeliners. To get it to stay in place, I sometimes put a bit of powder on the eyelid before lining the top lid with this eye liner. I've been using it for years...

I ordered this because of a youtube video influence, but I don't regret the purchase one bit. It is such a great quality eyeliner (I got dark brown) at a good price point. It's a gel-type liner, and actually it's a twist-up pencil, so there's no need for sharpening. It glides on super smoothly, and is very forgiving on wrinkly eyes. I bought it on the recommendation that you can wear it alone or smudge it easily for a smokey look. This is absolutely true. It smudges without tugging on the eyes and sets well, so it's long lasting. Colour is a nice deep warm brown. Pleasantly surprised also that I received 2 eyeliners in my purchase! I was expecting one, but I got two instead, so was extra pleased.

I love this eyeliner, it glides on so smoothly, with little effort. The thickness of the line is perfect. This eyeliner also doesn’t irritate my eyes like some of the other brands. The price on Amazon was a great deal, I should’ve bought more. Definitely will buy again.

Best eyeliner, great color - doesn’t smudge

Went on smoothly, easily smudgable, seemed to set. By the end of the day, it had traveled unflatteringly, even with setting spray.