365 by Whole Foods Market, Creamy Peanut Butter With Salt, 36 Ounce

At first I honestly hated it because it was grainy, but I mostly use it for my protein smoothies and it reeeeeally grew on me because the texture was actually great, I fell in love with it! Now I just tried buying 3 different kinds because I couldn’t remember which one I had. I accidentally got the organic ones:( they are flat out disgusting way too oily even after stirring it’s just too much but this one the grainyness is actually soooo good and now I’m pissed I literally bought all the other ones thinking it was the one and now I have to buy these lol fmlFirst pic is the jar basically licked clean, second is a pic of the empty one next to all the other terrible ones I bought trying to find this one again hahaAnyways I love it because the texture, at first it’s weird but it really grew on me. It’s finely ground but still has little itty bitty bits in it.If you don’t like that I’d recommend the organic version which has the brown cap in the 3rd photo.I don’t like it but that’s what you want if you want it to be perfectly creamy.

Thank you 365 Whole Foods Market for making this healthy whole food peanut butter available! I don't think most people fully understand how harmful it is to add sugar and hydrogenated oil like the average brand peanut butters do. That other stuff clogs you arteries and causes strokes and heart disease. Just peanuts and a little salt is as nature intended. I will gladly use my muscles and hands with opposable thumbs to re-join the peanutty goodness to its natural oil one time before I put it in the fridge. I am getting a great source of protein and omega fatty acids that taste so fresh with this HEALTHY NATURAL PEANUT BUTTER!

This stuff arrives with an inch of oil on top and the rest is like CLAY. You cannot, shake it or stir it. So I tried my immersion blender and BURNT the motor up. Some of the peanut butter did get blended, it's runny and still gritty, like they didn't fully break the peanuts down. Some of it is still like clumps of clay. What a mess and a waste of money and now I need a new immersion blender. I'm afraid to try any other brands after this.

I love this peanut butter. It has the most pure peanut taste of any brand, and there are no weird ingredients that don't belong in food. I recently moved to a rural area, and the closest Whole Foods is more than an hour away. So I was thrilled when I got an email saying that 365 products could now be ordered and shipped to me. I ordered the peanut butter and one other item I can't live without. Sadly the peanut butter arrived with the cap half off, the seal busted, and oily peanut butter all over the jars. Sigh. I guess this means a long drive in order to get my fave.

The peanut butter itself is alright, but one jar wasn't sealed properly or it may have been dropped prior to packing in the box. It leaked all inside the box and all over the jar. I'll keep it, but I'm not satisfied with whomever didn't do their job right and who can be blamed. As far as the peanut butter quality goes, it's the usual gritty texture as most of the natural kind are. I wish could have gotten these with no salt added. Salt works okay in conventional peanut butter, but not the natural kind like these. It just doesn't work for me. I still like Crazy Richards better, which has no salt added. I only wish they had larger jars like these.

I can’t stand the nut butters with added oils and sugar, so this one is it for me. Oil bothers my stomach so I actually pour out the oil on the top. I know you’re meant to mix it in, but I prefer it on the drier side anyway. Not really recommended since the vitamin e is mainly in the oil, but it might help you if peanuts upset your stomach sometimes.

Got this since Whole Foods only lets you purchase 4 of 16oz versions. Yes there's a lot of oil on top, just spill it out. It does have some old factory taste to it which the 16oz doesn't but it's still delicious and the best peanut butter in the USA. Ladies and Gent, you have been lied to your whole life, pb is not supposed to have added sugar, just salt, the way god intended.

since becoming a amazon product the consistency of the "creamy" has the texture of a brown mustard. NOT smooth, but gritty, like they aren't grinding peanuts fully any more. You will find pieces of peanut in your teeth. Awarded one extra star b/c it tastes fine - kinda hard to mess up peanuts and salt.