Sorme Treatment Cosmetics Smearproof Eyeliner 0.16oz | Long Lasting Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil | Smudge-Proof Waterline Eyeliner | Cruelty-Free and Gentle Pencil Eyeliner

I used to buy this color of eyeliner by "C" cosmetics, $35 + shipping + tax. I ran out and didn't want to pay as much, especially being summer and my makeup tends to run anyway. SORME is now my new eyeliner. This eyeliner is EXCELLENT! It's extremely reasonable, that's good, I didn't have tax, shipping, nor gas and time to go to the store. But the very best part is the quality. The color is deep and intense, obviously you can use less or more, it blends extremely well if you prefer it lighter. It goes on so very smooth, the liner doesn't stick and break off in a clump halfway across the lid as many do. It's also actually waterproof. Yes, it says that but in my experience it rarely is true. When you first apply it you do have a minute or so to blend, thin, thicken your line, then it's there and it stays there until you remove it. It even stays well on the inner rim above your bottom eyelashes. Another great thing about it is I didn't have to use a harsh remover to take it off. Mine came off with normal gentle warm water on a soft cloth, yes, water. But warm water, some extremely gentle facial soap. No pulling on gentle eye area skin. I did cry the first day I was wearing it and it held up very well to tears! I've tried quite a variety of eyeliner brands and colors, always had to go back to my old standby, but finally I have found the best eyeliner pencil yet. It even is better than the "C" brand which I feel is saying a whole lot. This jade green is my usual and favorite color but since SORME is of such high quality and so very reasonably priced I'm going to be trying some other colors as well. I'm extremely pleased to have run across this eyeliner. I'm sure I'll be a customer of SORME eyeliner for life. Thank you.

After Lancome apparently (annoyingly) discontinued Le Crayon Kohl's Black Lapis color (the one I've been using for MANY years - it was a beautiful color), I ordered all kinds of hopeful substitute eye pencils from Amazon. Most were awful. Of all of those pencils I ordered, ONLY this product - Sorme' Treatment Cosmetics Smear-Proof Eyeliner, Navy Blue - came close! Same beautiful color. It goes on smoothly and lasts most of the day, similar to Lancome's Le Crayon Kohl. I don't have a pencil sharpener that fits this smaller Sorme' pencil though. Doing my best with sharpeners I have. I will order this eyeliner pencil again! :)

I bought this by accident. Glad I did . Best long lasting smudge proof eye pencil I have bought

I read a lot of reviews trying to figure out which eyeliner to pick, since all the others I have tried seem to smudge after an hour. The reviews for this one all proclaimed that this was the one I’d been searching for! But sadly, this one ended up pretty much the same, it’s starts out nice but within an hour it’s slipping down my face.

The eyeliner itself was great. Sharpening a square pencil isn't the best, but just took more manual effort. I liked it enough to order again but I got two damaged pencils that look like they melted from heat either in transit or where they are stored. One had no tip and waxy stuff all over it. The other was crooked and also had a waxy residue. Returning them and not buying again because it's hot weather now and I think the same thing is going to happen.

The square design of the pencil gives it a nice grip for better precision when applying the eyeliner. Awkward to sharpen, but not bad enough to deter buying again. The color I bought is perfect for me. The application is smooth. I'd prefer it be a tad bit "creamier" but the pencil is not so hard that you really have rub it to make a mark on your eyelid.

I am incredibly picky when it comes to eyeliner, especially pencil eyeliner. I found this in Cosmoprof a few years ago and decided to give it a try- it’s now the only eyeliner pencil I use. Color is beautiful and it’s a high quality product! I typically use a liquid liner and then use this pencil to do the inside top lid. Things I love about this:Square shape of the pencil makes it easier to hold and maneuverIt stays put and lasts all daySharpens smoothly without the tip snapping off(I did have to find a new sharpener, as it doesn’t fit in the small holes of a traditional one)You definitely get your moneys worth out of this. Highly recommend!

I love this pencil! It's perfect.