Clio Sharp So Simple Waterproof Pencil Liner 003 Dark Brown

The waterproofness of this eyeliner was excellent. The product dragged on my eyelids and wasn't smooth. I was hoping that Cacao Brown was a deeper brown that matched the photos. It had more red and warmth than I was hoping for.

If you're looking for waterproof eyeliner keep looking. This barely lasts 20-30 mins on the eye. I bought cacao brown. If you're looking at that colour just know its more of a red toned brown sort of like a red clay terracotta colour.