Maybelline TattooStudio Long-Lasting Sharpenable Eyeliner Pencil, Glide on Smooth Gel Pigments with 36 Hour Wear, Waterproof, Intense Charcoal, 1 Count

I purchased the black and white pencils and they work great! Easy to apply and lets you smudge it a bit before it sets which is perfect because I make mistakes a lot. Doesn't flake off. Stays on all day. Between a hard and soft pencil consistency. I like it better than the Urban Decay brand pencil I have because it was too soft for me. Works great with my Revlon eye pencil sharpener!

Amazing, it is water proof, lasts all day long, it's very soft, you barely need to press down at all to get a thick black line of color, it stays on the water line, and gives you the perfect eyeliner look, does not smudge at all, incredibly easy to apply and stays on until you take it off, you do have to have makeup wipes to get it off, but considering how long it lasts, that's an amazing feature. Absolutely worth the price.

I love this product, and have it in many colors. Goes on very nicely and stays put. Comes off easily with a makeup remover pad, and I love I don't have to rub to get it off. You can't beat this quality for the price!

This eyeliner seriously impressed me with how bold and rich the pigment is. The Deep Onyx shade is a true, intense black that shows up immediately with just one swipe, no need to go over it multiple times. It glides on really smoothly, almost like a gel, so it’s easy to apply even on delicate areas like the waterline.Once it sets, it stays put. I’ve worn it for long days, in heat and humidity, and it doesn’t smudge or fade. Definitely lives up to the “36-hour wear” claim. It’s also waterproof, so tears or rain won’t budge it.One thing to know: it’s a sharpenable pencil, not a twist-up. You’ll want a sharpener that can handle soft, creamy pencils, because the formula is rich and smooth, but once sharpened properly, the application is flawless.If you’re looking for a super pigmented, long-lasting liner that won’t let you down by the end of the day, this one delivers big time.

Love this stuff. Stays on. Looks nice. Not all over your face.

the pencil is great when you first open the package, but it doesn't sharpen well, you'll lose a lot of the pencil trying to get a decent point-tip again. Color is nice, stays on fairly well. Minimal smudging.

I love this eye liner. It lasts all day long. It is a bit hard to sharpen, but for me it's worth it. It's worth trying if you need something long lasting. It works best if you let it set for a minute before you put the rest of your eye makeup on. Otherwise it might smudge a bit when you first put it on.

I buy this one quite often it is my favorite eyeliner. I just purchased one and even though it was supposed to be shipping with other items it was not in my package. Again, this is not an expensive eyeliner but I more than appreciate amazon reaching out and re-sending a new one in its own package. I will def continue to purchase this eyeliner since I use it so much but always from this vendor. This eyeliner is the best for me. the brown is perfect and glides on. It runs a bit but most eyeliners do.